May 05, 2005

A*Star confirms warning to student over defamatory blog

Channelnewsasia.com reports

A*Star (Agency for Science, Technology and Research) confirmed it had warned a Singapore student of legal consequences over a public blog containing defamatory statements...

... So it warned the blogger of legal consequences unless the objectionable statements were removed and an acceptable apology published.

A*Star also said it welcomed a diversity of views in all media, but the statements made in the blog "went way beyond fair comment.

CNA: Link1, Link 2

[cowboycaleb: Interesting... got warning still not scared....]
Submitted by YC on May 05//10:11pm and published by cowboycaleb :: 2213 reads | trackback (2)
Comments 9

Sigh. What's the point of Blogging if we may get sued for what we typed?

free speech does not mean irresponsible speech.

Some choice quotes from the article:

> On Wednesday, Channel NewsAsia broke a story

Yes, "broke". Many weeks late.

> It [A*Star] also said it had the responsibility to protect its reputation and also that of Singapore.

Protecting the reputation of being a state where nobody can speak freely? I suppose that worked, international media did pick up on the story...

caleb: The official word is that warning is given. Wouldn't do very nicely for their reputation if they just went around slapping lawsuits on people, would it ? Official word on official media.

Trackback from Wannabe Lawyer:

Credit for the ‘ChannelNewsLater‘ part of the title goes to Mr Miyagi. So ChannelNewsLater is behind the curve when it comes to news from the blogosphere. Is it any surprising? All those layers of bureaucracy to go through, checking with ......

I noticed AcidFlask's reply got pulled of this site rather quickly this morning. What happened?

Posted by liz* on 6 May, 2005 - 10:34am

waiting for permission from AcidFlask to publish it.

ASTAR could have created a blog and replied to the criticism. I remember an incident in China a while back. Villagers in Gansu province created a Blog to protest against the local government for taking away their farmland. Such evictions are becoming common in China - with farmland being used to bulid factories. Usually, in China such protest webs or blogs are immediately blocked. But in this case, the local government created their own blog to counter some of the points raised in the villager's blog.

More here
http://www.tinydust.net/jsjy/sxl/2004/10/blog.html

Trackback from YC:

Thanks a lot. Now, besides the beaten-to-death topic of Singapore's ban on chewing gum*, I have to think of an appropriate response for the blogger lawsuit case when spreading the good name of Singapore to my international friends...